The upcoming Harry Potter television reboot, set to premiere on Max in 2026, has ignited fierce debate following the casting of British actor Paapa Essiedu as Severus Snape. Daniel Radcliffe, the iconic Harry Potter from the original film series, has publicly criticized the decision, reportedly stating, “Please remove him from the cast,” after learning that Snape, traditionally depicted as a white character, would be played by a Black actor. The comment, which surfaced on social media platforms like X on May 6, 2025, has sparked a polarized reaction, with fans and commentators divided over issues of race, fidelity to J.K. Rowling’s source material, and the creative direction of the reboot. Radcliffe’s stance, detailed in a viral video titled “Daniel Radcliffe Critica a HBO, ELIMINEN a Severus Snape Negro,” has intensified scrutiny on the project.

The Harry Potter reboot, announced by Warner Bros. Discovery in 2023, aims to adapt Rowling’s seven books into a decade-long series, promising a deeper exploration of Hogwarts’ world. Essiedu, known for roles in I May Destroy You and The Lazarus Project, was cast as Snape, the complex Potions master and antihero, in a move hailed by some as a bold step toward diversity. However, the decision has drawn backlash from fans who argue that Snape’s appearance—described in the books as pale with greasy black hair—should remain consistent. Posts on X, such as one from @popculture_show on May 7, 2025, claim Rowling herself “refuses to fire” Essiedu, despite pressure to align with fans’ expectations. The post, quoting Rowling’s alleged defense of the casting, has fueled accusations of “woke” agendas, with some users calling Essiedu’s casting “a major mistake.”

Radcliffe, who played Harry Potter from 2001 to 2011, has long been vocal about supporting progressive causes, including trans rights, which put him at odds with Rowling. His reported objection to Essiedu’s casting, however, has surprised many, given his advocacy for inclusivity. The video, shared by @Draculordx, suggests Radcliffe believes the casting deviates too far from the books’ canon, potentially alienating fans. “Snape’s look is iconic; it’s not about race but staying true to the character,” Radcliffe allegedly said, per the clip’s subtitles. Critics on X argue this stance contradicts his prior calls for diversity, with @HogwartsLegacyFan tweeting, “Radcliffe can’t have it both ways—preaching inclusion but rejecting a Black Snape.” Others, like @PotterPurist, support him, insisting that Snape’s physical description is integral to his brooding persona.

The controversy highlights broader tensions in adapting beloved franchises. Rowling, an executive producer, has emphasized “faithfulness” to her novels, yet her reported approval of Essiedu suggests openness to reinterpretation. Director Francesca Gardiner and showrunner Mark Mylod have defended the casting, with Gardiner telling Variety in April 2025 that Essiedu’s “intensity and nuance” make him ideal for Snape’s layered character. Essiedu himself has remained silent, but sources close to the production, cited by Deadline, claim he’s faced “vile” online harassment, echoing the racist backlash against Black actors like Moses Ingram in Star Wars. This has prompted supporters, including @WizardingWorld4All on X, to rally behind Essiedu, praising his talent and condemning the “toxic” fandom’s gatekeeping.

The reboot’s casting choices extend beyond Snape, with newcomer Joshua Pickering as Harry, Ty Tennant as Ron, and Abby Ryder Fortson as Hermione, aiming for a younger ensemble to reflect the books’ timeline. Yet, Snape’s casting has dominated discourse, with some fans on X speculating that HBO might recast under pressure, though no official statement confirms this. The series, filmed in Leavesden, UK, is deep into production, with Rowling’s involvement ensuring a balance between canon and innovation. However, Radcliffe’s comments, whether fully verified or amplified by social media, have complicated the narrative, raising questions about his influence as a franchise alum.

As the Harry Potter reboot approaches, the controversy underscores the challenges of reimagining a cultural touchstone. Essiedu’s Snape could redefine the character, bringing fresh depth to his tragic arc, but only if the fandom’s divisiveness doesn’t overshadow the effort. Radcliffe’s reported plea, while divisive, reflects the passion Harry Potter inspires, even as it risks fueling further rancor. With filming ongoing and fan reactions simmering on X, the series faces a delicate path to balance legacy and progress, leaving Essiedu’s performance as a potential lightning rod for change—or a casualty of fan backlash.