Carrie Underwood Sparks Debate as ‘American Idol’ 2025 Heads Toward the Grand Finale

Three standout contestants have secured their spots in the American Idol 2025 finale after a magical Disney-themed night filled with show-stopping performances—and intense controversy surrounding judge Carrie Underwood.

A Fairytale Look with Real-World Reactions

Dressed in a stunning Rapunzel-inspired purple gown, Carrie turned heads with delicate floral embroidery and a dramatic thigh-high slit. Her long blonde hair flowed to her silver stilettos, adorned with purple floral accents. She shared her look on Instagram with the caption:
“It’s a #DisneyNight fit check! #CUonIDOL”, captivating many fans—though not everyone was pleased.

While her appearance fit the Disney theme, Underwood’s judging on the May 12 episode drew criticism. Some viewers accused her of being biased, too harsh, and favoring certain contestants—especially during her critique of Jamal Roberts.

Comments flooded in, including:
“Get rid of her. Her bias is showing.”
“I wish there was a way to vote her off 🙄.”

While some criticized her tone and delivery, others came to her defense, praising her honesty and charisma.

Top 3 Finalists Announced

During the episode, the Top 5 contestants each performed two songs—one as a Disney hero and one as a villain. After an unforgettable night, Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were eliminated.

Slater Nalley:
🎵 “You’ve Got a Friend in Me” (Toy Story)
🎵 “Born to Be Wild” (D3: The Mighty Ducks)

Thunderstorm Artis:
🎵 “A Dream Is a Wish Your Heart Makes” (Cinderella)
🎵 “Find Yourself” (Cars)

The finalists moving on to the May 18 grand finale are:

John Foster – “The Bare Necessities” (The Jungle Book) & “Rainbow Connection” (The Muppet Movie)
Jamal Roberts – “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” (Remember the Titans) & “Beauty and the Beast”
Breanna Nix – “This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)” (The Parent Trap) & “You’ll Be in My Heart” (Tarzan)

Viral “Fit Check” Video Adds Fuel to the Fire

Beyond her critiques, Carrie Underwood made headlines earlier this season with a viral “Fit Check” video posted by American Idol. Dressed in a bold denim-inspired dress with ruffled details and a dramatic bow, she showcased her fashion flair.

However, the reaction online was split. While some admired her look and called her “fit and fabulous,” others criticized her appearance, speculating about cosmetic changes:
“What did she do to her lips?”
“Too much filler.”
“She was beautiful without all that.”

Despite the backlash, loyal fans praised her confidence and beauty.

Miranda Lambert Divides Viewers with Live Performance

On May 4, Miranda Lambert returned to the Idol stage as a guest mentor and performer. Singing her hit song “Kerosene,” she rocked a black western-inspired outfit with silver accents. Yet, opinions were once again divided.